most of the vouches here are without reason or have improper responses.
"vouch because epic" isn't a valid vote - and just simply stating "vouch" isn't valid either.
it seems that the majority of objections are backed up with valid reasons, whereas the vouches are just out of please
holy shit shdwo redemption arc?
but anyway yeah i agree - votes need proper justification i.e.
↩ ThatOneLiviRealAccount i remember him being a very good event host
instead of nothing or stuff that means nothing, not gonna use any examples here cuz calling out
im going to start striking users for fucking powerposting if all they gotta say is "vouch", am i talking to a brick fuckin wall?
if you got a verdict, leave atleast a somewhat fucking valid reason as per this that i've FUCKING SENT AND SAID MULTIPLE TIMES
vouch user will be a very important asset to the team because he is clearly changed and is having potential to become the greatest
vouch i have talked with him in a chat with lyicx and i trust you 😃
Neither is "he might do it again". Let's be honest: how could anyone prove they haved changed if they are not able to prove that they have? People like Luke are here objecting because of what they think because he "hasn't changed". How do you know? Adding to this, which idiot would do the same thing after being DEMOTED for it?
i didn't cast a vote. i was asking a question. i don't generally vote on these things.
Cuz we have to look at his behaviour in order to make a judgement. His behaviour is the exact same. He has not changed, and therefore it's reasonable to assume his behaviour will be the same meaning he will do the same things.
proving someone has changed is hard, yes, but when they talk and overall behave in the same way while yelling 'ive changed i wont do it again'. its one thing to say 'ive changed' but when your behaviour and mannerisms don't show it then it ultimately means nothing
my bad, though i'd say a negative criticism is on par with an object even though you're not directly voting
We're jumping from a to z here. Just because i talk like an idiot doesnt mean im going to be harassing someone again
but in the same strand it'd be reasonable to assume someone who previously abused has not changed their attitude towards abusing. Op said he'd even find it funny. you however did apologise and have shown genuine change
yeah I get that but I really doubt he will actually abuse his perms again. heck before getting the perms he did host numerous events and was a pretty decent host overall.
i'd say theres a difference between muting people as a joke and finding it funny (like most admins and mods on TF) and making fun of someone's appearance. Not saying he was in the right to abuse but i don't think he meant to deliberately use his perms to harm the server. It was probably the fact that op saw other admins joke muting eachother.
bump : D
I will reach a verdict by tomorrow sometime, since this has been open for almost a month.
User has withdrawn their application.
