Currently, Hub Mod applications have a requirement you must state your reason on why you voted. This suggestion is to extend it to all current and future applications, and ban appeals. In order to vote, you must state a valid reason on why you decided to vouch, object, or went neutral. In order for the reason to be considered "valid", it must be based on the person's character and not your opinion of the person ("vouch, i like this person" or "object! i hate this person" are not valid reasons) and your reason cannot also be based on another person's vote ("vouch because
ALTERNATIVE SUGGESTION:
Instead of completely nullifying people who didn't state a reason, we just give extra weight for those who did instead.